Exploring the Different Styles of Leadership

Leadership is not one-size-fits-all. Over time, various leadership styles have emerged, each offering unique insights and approaches for inspiring and guiding others. From the charm of charismatic leadership to the ethical grounding of authentic leadership, from the dynamism of adaptive leadership to the motivational drive of transformational leadership, understanding these theories helps leaders navigate challenges and drive change. This article explores the strengths and limitations of six prominent leadership styles—charismatic, authentic, adaptive, transactional, transformational, and servant leadership—and considers their practical applications in different contexts.

Max Weber was a German sociologist. He wrote about charismatic leadership as part of his broader work on the theory of authority and bureaucracy in his 1922 essay "Economy and Society".

Charismatic leadership theory suggests that leaders can inspire followers through their personal charisma, vision and charm.

Charismatic leaders are seen as transformational figures who can create strong emotional connections with their followers, instill a sense of purpose and mobilise them towards shared goals.

Charismatic leadership theory often centres on the individual leader, so it neglects the importance of institutional and structural aspects of leadership. It doesn’t provide a clear pathway for leadership development within organisations because it gives the impression that leaders are born, not developed.

Authentic leadership is a theory described by Bill George in his book "Authentic Leadership: Rediscovering the Secrets to Creating Lasting Value" in 2003.

Authentic leadership focuses on leaders' genuine and self-aware expressions of their values, emotions and beliefs.

Authentic leaders are seen by others to be transparent, self-reflective, and consistent with their principles.

Authentic leadership is valuable because it promotes trust, ethical behavior and follower engagement.

It’s worth considering what “authentic” might actually mean, and considering how as a leader you can remain balanced between maintaining vision and values, and adapting to different circumstances and people, and developing yourself through learning. Sticking to what you feel is your “authentic self” risks a narrow-minded approach that doesn’t learn from others and is seen to be out of touch with followers. In complex, results-driven environments, the emphasis on authenticity may not always lead to effective decision-making or problem-solving.

Adaptive leadership theory is a leadership framework that was first developed by Dr Ronald Heifetz and Dr Marty Linsky in the early 1990s.

Adaptive leadership is a dynamic approach that community leaders can use in general, but it’s most useful when you’re seeking to address complex challenges and drive positive change. ‘Complex challenges’ are problems that lack straightforward solutions and require innovative thinking and adaptability.

Adaptive leadership emphasises the ability of leaders to mobilise and empower their followers to adapt to changing circumstances and thrive in the face of uncertainty. That’s no small thing! Humans are not always fantastic with change.

Adaptive leadership theory can be bitsy and difficult to implement. The theory often requires leaders to navigate uncharted territory, which can be overwhelming and demanding, particularly in organisations or communities with deeply ingrained traditions and practices. Speaking with a coach or mentor about the changes you are seeking to drive can be helpful.

Transactional leadership theory was first introduced in the early 20th century and further developed over time. It is associated with the work of sociologist Max Weber and, in the late 1970s, James MacGregor Burns.

In transactional leadership, leaders and followers engage in a transaction where followers provide effort, compliance or loyalty, and leaders in return provide rewards or punishments based on performance.

Transformational leadership is a leadership theory that was first introduced by James MacGregor Burns in his 1978 book Leadership. Burns developed this theory to describe a leadership style that goes beyond transactional exchange to inspire and motivate followers to achieve exceptional results.

Transformational leaders inspire and motivate their followers by presenting a compelling vision of the future. This vision can ignite enthusiasm and commitment, making people feel that their work has purpose and meaning.

Transformational leaders empower their followers, providing them with the autonomy to make decisions, take risks, and be creative. This fosters a sense of ownership and personal growth.

Transformational leadership is best suited to workplaces and individuals with certain personality traits and needs. While transformational leadership can be highly effective in many contexts, it may not be the best fit for all situations or for leaders and staff who prioritise clarity, structure or risk minimisation.

Enrol in ICDA’s NFP Leadership Certificate. This comprehensive program equips nonprofit leaders with practical tools for governance, communication, and strategic decision-making.

Why Choose This Program?

• Tailored for nonprofit and community leaders.
• Learn from governance and strategy experts.
• Apply lessons directly to your organisation for immediate impact.

Invest in your leadership journey today to become the leader your organisation and community need.