
Progressive thinkers plan push for tax changes
Posted on 07 Jul 2025
A community tax summit that brought together over 100 economists and sector leaders in Melbourne…
Posted on 14 Nov 2024
By Matthew Schulz, journalist, Institute of Community Directors Australia
Studies of Australian boards reveal that small not-for-profits are falling behind larger organisations on most performance measures.
Board Surveys, part of the Insync group, has assessed more than 500 Australian boards over two decades with its board assessment survey tools. Now, findings provided exclusively to ICDA as part of a new partnership arrangement are set to serve as a wake-up call to the nation’s community directors and committee members.
ICDA and Board Surveys this week launched a new survey and benchmarking tool designed for small not-for-profit boards, committees and governance bodies.
Board Surveys agreed to dip into its data to examine how small NFP boards are performing, and the news is alarming. An analysis of hundreds of past Board Surveys assessments shows that small not-for-profits underperform compared to other boards on most of 14 key metrics. These include clarity on the board’s role, leadership, boardroom dynamics, relations with management, information control, managing meetings, strategy setting, establishing culture, promoting good risk management, succession planning, and a commitment to continuous improvement.
According to the analysis, small not-for-profit boards particularly struggled with:
The analysis also showed that:
A concern for boards of all sizes is that the Insync surveys show that one quarter of all boards (whether from for-profit or not-for-profit organisations) are “dysfunctional”.
Asked about what made a board effective, based on his firm’s studies, Board Surveys executive chair Nicholas Barnett identified five top attributes:
Barnett said it was generally more effective for boards to focus on a few key areas likely to lead to the greatest improvements than to spread their attention widely.
For example, a recent detailed analysis of golf club governance by Board Surveys found that many club boards and committees were overly involved in the day-to-day management and operations of their club.
The report observed: “Director over-reach into the operations of the organisation is not unique to golf clubs. It happens in organisations of all types and shapes and sizes in Australia and beyond.”
The study prompted four recommendations for improving these boards:
Barnett said Board Surveys planned to uncover and share new insights about effective boards based on the survey tool being released to ICDA members this week.
Posted on 07 Jul 2025
A community tax summit that brought together over 100 economists and sector leaders in Melbourne…
Posted on 26 Jun 2025
Most not-for-profit workers are falling behind on wages, according to the latest national sector…
Posted on 26 Jun 2025
It’s that time of year when organisations are really focused on their finances, and that means…
Posted on 26 Jun 2025
I once worked for a small not-for-profit that decided to host a small public event at its offices.
Posted on 26 Jun 2025
ICDA training lead Nina Laitala examines the governance issues facing Australian not-for-profits.
Posted on 25 Jun 2025
Vicki Meyer has made promoting volunteering her life’s work. The Institute of Community Directors…
Posted on 25 Jun 2025
Revenue for Australia’s charity and not-for-profit sector has reached record highs, and total…
Posted on 25 Jun 2025
In Australia’s charity sector, there’s no shortage of passion or ideas – but there is a shortage of…
Posted on 25 Jun 2025
Boards should be alert to a series of recent updates and regulatory shifts in accounting standards…
Posted on 21 May 2025
As more not-for-profits (NFPs) embrace digital transformation, Doug Taylor, chief executive of The…
Posted on 21 May 2025
I was brought up by a Dylan-loving Boomer, marching against war and nuclear bombs, worried about…
Posted on 21 May 2025
Charities Minister Andrew Leigh says the new Labor government will press ahead with a “big and…